A structured interview is an interview where every candidate gets the same job related questions, in the same order, and is scored on the same rating scale. It is fairer and predicts job performance better than an informal, free flowing conversation.
Recruitingtopic
2 minread
2related terms
In one line
An interview where every candidate gets the same job related questions and is scored on the same scale. It is fairer and predicts job performance better than a free flowing chat.
Building one starts with a job analysis: what skills and behaviors the role needs. Each question targets one of those competencies, usually as a behavioral question about past experience or a situational question about a likely scenario. Interviewers use a scorecard with a defined rating scale, often one to five, and short descriptions of what weak, good and strong answers look like.
The US Office of Personnel Management describes structured interviews as one of the most reliable and valid selection methods available and encourages federal agencies to use them. The structure also helps with fairness, because every candidate is judged on the same criteria. Interviewers can still ask follow up questions, as long as they stay on the same competencies.
Why it matters to recruiters
Unstructured interviews let gut feel, small talk and likeability drive decisions, which leads to poor hires and bias. Structured interviews give hiring managers a clear, defensible basis for choosing, make debriefs faster and help recruiters push back on vague feedback like not a culture fit. They also make it easier to compare candidates seen by different interviewers.
An example from a recruiting desk
A support team hires ten agents a quarter. The recruiter builds six questions covering problem solving, written communication and handling an angry customer, each with a one to five scale and example answers. Every interviewer uses the same scorecard. Debriefs drop from 45 minutes to 15, and the team can now see which interviewers score far higher or lower than others.
Tips that help
Base every question on a skill or behavior the job actually requires.
Write anchor examples for low, middle and high scores before interviews start.
Have interviewers score independently before the debrief discussion.
Train interviewers to take notes on evidence, not impressions.
Mistakes to avoid
Calling an interview structured when only the first question is fixed.
Letting interviewers change the scoring scale or skip questions they dislike.
Which tools help?
A few of the interviewing tools in our directory. Prices are the published starting price on the date we last checked.
What is the difference between a structured and an unstructured interview?
A structured interview uses the same job related questions and the same scoring scale for every candidate. An unstructured interview lets the interviewer ask whatever comes up. Structured interviews are more consistent, fairer and better at predicting performance.
Are structured interviews boring for candidates?
They do not have to be. Interviewers can open with a warm introduction, explain the format and leave time for the candidate's questions. Many candidates find a clear structure fairer, because they know they are judged on the same points as everyone else.
How many questions should a structured interview have?
Most have five to ten questions for a 45 to 60 minute interview, leaving room for follow ups and candidate questions. Cover each key competency once or twice rather than asking many shallow questions.
