Compare/Head to head

Sherlock AI vs SimpleHire

Same facts, side by side: starting price, free tier, MCP, API and what each one is actually built for.

Starting price

Sherlock AI

$50 prepaid credits Free trial

Sherlock AI detects proxy, lip-sync, and deepfake signals in live interviews. It is pay as you go: credits start at $50, about 5 to 10 interviews, and new accounts get $20 in free credits.

Where Sherlock AI fits

  • TA teams running remote video interviews that need proxy and deepfake signals
  • Orgs that permit some AI use and want an AI Fluency score beside fraud
  • Teams that want automated notes on the same Sherlock session
  • Companies that prefer unlimited seats and pay per interview instead of per interviewer

SimpleHire

$2/screen Free tier

SimpleHire runs a proctored AI voice interview and skill check on a candidate before you send them to the client, and returns a scored report plus a shareable certificate. It is priced per screen from $2, with 25 free Basic screens a month, but ATS integration is still coming soon. Best for staffing desks that want proof attached to submissions, not for teams shopping for an ATS.

Where SimpleHire fits

  • Staffing recruiters who submit verified profiles to clients instead of raw resumes
  • Desks filling junior, technical or high-value roles that need skill evidence
  • Agencies screening at volume that want a low per-screen price and a free monthly allowance
  • Teams that want an optional ID and face-match check without a separate vendor

At a glance

DetailSherlock AISimpleHire
Starting price$50 prepaid credits$2/screen
Free tier–No✓Yes
Free trialYesNot on record
MCP server–No–No
Public API–No–No
Listed underCandidate fraud & AI detectionAssessments, Background check, Candidate fraud & AI detection, Interviewing

Where they pull apart

Sherlock AI

Stands out: Plans split into Only Fraud Detection, Fraud plus AI Fluency, and a full suite that adds automated interview notes, all with unlimited seats under fair use.

Watch out: Cost per interview depends on which checks each interview uses, so $50 of credits covers anywhere from about 5 to 10 interviews. Enterprise volume pricing is quoted.

Not the right fit for

  • Desks that need a published ATS-named integration list before buying
  • Buyers who want a fixed monthly price per interview

SimpleHire

Stands out: Pricing is published and per screen ($2, $3 or $5) with 25 free Basic screens every month and no card, which is rare for proctored screening. Each report pairs a role-based voice interview that follows up on weak answers with skill evidence and integrity signals, and the candidate can keep the result as a verified profile.

Watch out: ATS integration is not live yet: Ceipal and JobDiva come first, then Bullhorn, so today the report is attached to submissions by hand. The ID and face-match check is optional and its price is not listed separately. Proctoring signals are flagged for a human to review rather than decided automatically, and the vendor positions the tool as pre-screening evidence, not a background check.

Not the right fit for

  • In-house TA teams shopping for an ATS with pipelines and job posts
  • Buyers who need live ATS writeback on day one
  • Teams that need an FCRA background check

Pros and cons

Sherlock AI

  • Pay as you go from $50 in credits with no subscription
  • Optional AI Fluency and automated notes on the same session
  • $20 in free credits to test about 2 to 4 interviews
  • Per-interview cost varies with the checks each interview uses
  • ATS integrations are advertised without named systems on the pricing page
  • Not an interviewer. It sits on the live video you already run

SimpleHire

  • Published per-screen prices from $2, with no contract
  • 25 free Basic screens a month, no card
  • Proctoring covers browser, desktop and optional second-device views
  • Candidate owns the verified result and certificate
  • ATS integration is coming soon, not live
  • Not an ATS. No job pipeline or client CRM
  • Optional ID check pricing is not listed on the page

What each one costs

Sherlock AI

$50 prepaid credits

Pay as you go: add credits in dollars, minimum $50 ($50, $100, $250, $500 or any amount from $50 up). $50 covers about 5 to 10 interviews depending on the checks each interview uses. New accounts get $20 in free credits, about 2 to 4 interviews. Enterprise is volume pricing with invoicing and yearly contracts. Confirm current terms on the vendor site.

Checked 4 Nov 2026

SimpleHire

$2/screen

Pay per screen with no contract: Basic is $2 (8 questions, about 15 minutes), Adaptive is $3 (follow-up questions, about 20 minutes) and Advanced is $5 (deep dive, about 30 minutes, optional coding round scored separately). Every workspace gets 25 free Basic screens a month with no card. An ID check can be added when a client requires it. Confirm current terms on the vendor site.

Checked 4 Nov 2026

Common questions

Is Sherlock AI cheaper than SimpleHire?
SimpleHire starts lower, at $2/screen against $50 prepaid credits for Sherlock AI. That is the entry plan on each side, so the real number depends on seats and the tier you land on.
Can you try Sherlock AI or SimpleHire for free?
SimpleHire carries a free tier on our listing. Sherlock AI offers a free trial.

Not the pair you wanted?

All Sherlock AI alternatives All SimpleHire alternatives Every Candidate fraud & AI detection tool

Editorial listings, never paid rankings. Prices checked 4 Nov 2026. Confirm current terms on the vendor site. Spot an error?